Come Gallop On with Me

« My big horse needs some big attention | Main | Dust »

Straight from the horse's mouth

magister.jpg

Disclosure: Straight from the horse's mouth is where I get to be opininated.

We had a little brush with the real Magisterium this week.

My little ten- and eleven-year-olds go to catechism class when they are with their dad and stepmom. They told me that their catechism teacher (I have no idea who this person is) told them that they would "hurt God's feelings, that God would hate them, and turn his back on them" if they went to see this movie The Golden Compass, which, of course, they and several other kids in the class had already seen. In fact, I know my children's dad took them to this fantasy movie based upon a series of popular fantasy books, because Dennis and I wound up sitting with them (that old bobcat thing again) during the show, as we were all there at the same time, quite by coincidence.

As you can imagine, my children were upset by the teacher's statements, but they've got good enough heads on their shoulders to ask questions, which they did, of me, anyway. Initially, I was so amazed by the whole thing I told the kids that certainly a catechism teacher wouldn't tell kids that God would "hate" them if they did something or other like going to a movie. But they both confirmed that the teacher did indeed say that.

[ Pardon my snorting sounds of complete incredulity here ... ]

I teach my kids to think for themselves, but they are also kids, and vulnerable to people with agendas that are, in this instance, not very nice and who apparently aren't concerned about using some pretty severe scare tactics to push their agenda on innocent children. (Yeah, let's scare them into the fold.) I told the kids that a person like this wouldn't dare make a statement of this type to a group of thinking adults who are half awake. Because someone would say, "I disagree with you wholeheartedly." Heck, they might even get up and leave. I would. And if I had my act together, all the synapses and sparks firing, I would manage to do it politely. But kids are easy targets for this stuff, I told them. I told them that just because someone is in a position of authority doesn't mean they've cornered the market on the truth, or that they're necessarily even interested in it.

I told them that teacher was full of shit. (OK. I'm not always polite. You may have to squint your eyes to see the spark of the divine in me sometimes.)

bfcompass1.jpg

Straight from the horse's mouth--It's not my church, but I've spent quality time with the righteous, and I'd bet you not one parent in the herd crowd said a word about that teacher's statement. (That convenient word infallibility, with all its trappings of earthly power, just leaves me cold. Chilled. To the bone.) And with the historical troubles with RCC priests here in this neck of the woods, I wonder who would bother to listen to their bleating?

I've decided to leave it alone and not call the church, since I'm not a member there. Taking on the system only sucks me in, which is not where I want to go. I patched this up with my own two kids, which is all I can do, and I think they even learned something important. As for me... Yes, I can acknowledge the sparks, even though they are buried somewhere deep down, layer upon layer, and I feel a sense of pity and loss for the person who is so sound asleep, so lost in the dream, that he/she made this terrifying statement to a group of impressionable little kids, but I stay as far away from these folks as possible.

Gentle as a dove and wise as a fox? Read that somewhere, and I kind of like the idea.

Good to get that one off the ol' chest.

Comments

This is the second blog I have read about Christians hating this movie. I guess I'll have to go and see it now. I really do wish folks would stop trying to scare kids and argue adults to God.

Wow, Kimberley, that is some heavy shit to lay on kids. Fear is a pretty effective motivator and brainwash tool. I'm so glad you could all discuss this, and that you're showing them how to think for themselves about these big issues.

It IS possible to be a truly spiritual and good Christian person [that spark of the divine thing, I guess] without all this crazy fundamentalist shit. Whatever happened to basic commandments and precepts as "love one another as I have loved you" [thus "treat others as you would be treated"] and "we are all equal in the eyes of God"? As for taking on the system; one can't have a rational debate with an irrational person/organisation.

What you report is incredible. Whatever happened to Jesus loving sinners, and "all those who truly seek God finding Him"?

There is a great deal in many modern films that might be used as the basis for talking to children about morals. Helping them to appreciate that some things are right, some are wrong, and some offer legitimate choices. Not by trying to scare them as if they were superstitious medieval peasants.

"Papal infallibility" is a relatively recent Roman Catholic doctrine (19th century, I think) created by a weak Pope to bolster his authority. It has no doctrinal basis in traditional Christianity.

"Medieval peasants" -- spectacular!

I will be smiling for days about that one, Julian.

Pax. Kimberly

Post a comment